Peter Schiff &#273;&atilde; tham gia tranh lu&#7853;n v&#7899;i CZ t&#7841;i Binance Blockchain Week sau khi th&aacute;ch th&#7913;c t&iacute;nh h&#7907;p ph&aacute;p c&#7911;a Bitcoin nh&#432; l&agrave; m&#7897;t c&ocirc;ng c&#7909; t&#7841;o ra gi&aacute; tr&#7883; kinh t&#7871; th&#7921;c s&#7921;.
Ph&aacute;t bi&#7875;u tr&ecirc;n s&acirc;n kh&#7845;u &#273;&#7889;i di&#7879;n Changpeng Zhao (CZ), Schiff cho r&#7857;ng Bitcoin ch&#7881; l&agrave; m&#7897;t chuy&#7875;n giao t&agrave;i s&#7843;n c&oacute; t&#7893;ng b&#7857;ng kh&ocirc;ng thay v&igrave; l&agrave; m&#7897;t t&agrave;i s&#7843;n c&oacute; gi&aacute; tr&#7883; s&#7843;n xu&#7845;t.
D&#432;&#7899;i &#273;&acirc;y l&agrave; tuy&ecirc;n b&#7889; &#273;&#7847;y &#273;&#7911; c&#7911;a Schiff &#273;&#432;&#7907;c &#273;&#432;a ra trong cu&#7897;c tranh lu&#7853;n:
<blockquote class="max-w-xl text-4.5 border-l-2 border-blue-600 pl-11 mb-9 select-all [&amp;_p]:!mb-0 wp-block-quote is-layout-flow wp-block-quote-is-layout-flow">
&ldquo;T&#7845;t c&#7843; nh&#7919;ng g&igrave; Bitcoin l&agrave;m l&agrave; cho ph&eacute;p chuy&#7875;n giao t&agrave;i s&#7843;n t&#7915; nh&#7919;ng ng&#432;&#7901;i mua BTC sang nh&#7919;ng ng&#432;&#7901;i b&aacute;n n&oacute;. Khi Bitcoin &#273;&#432;&#7907;c t&#7841;o ra, kh&ocirc;ng c&oacute; t&agrave;i s&#7843;n th&#7853;t s&#7921;. Ch&uacute;ng ta c&oacute; kho&#7843;ng 20 tri&#7879;u Bitcoin m&agrave; ch&uacute;ng ta kh&ocirc;ng c&oacute; c&aacute;ch &#273;&acirc;y 15 n&#259;m. Nh&#432;ng ch&uacute;ng ta kh&ocirc;ng gi&agrave;u h&#417;n v&igrave; BTC &#273;&oacute; t&#7891;n t&#7841;i. Ch&uacute;ng kh&ocirc;ng th&#7921;c s&#7921; l&agrave;m &#273;&#432;&#7907;c g&igrave;. Nh&#432;ng &#273;i&#7873;u &#273;&atilde; x&#7843;y ra l&agrave; m&#7897;t s&#7889; ng&#432;&#7901;i &#273;&atilde; tr&#7903; n&ecirc;n gi&agrave;u l&ecirc;n nh&#7901; chi ph&iacute; c&#7911;a nh&#7919;ng ng&#432;&#7901;i kh&aacute;c. Hi&#7879;n t&#7841;i, nh&#7919;ng ng&#432;&#7901;i &#273;&atilde; m&#7845;t r&#7845;t nhi&#7873;u ti&#7873;n v&agrave;o Bitcoin th&#7853;m ch&iacute; c&ograve;n kh&ocirc;ng nh&#7853;n ra r&#7857;ng h&#7885; &#273;&atilde; m&#7845;t ti&#7873;n, v&igrave; h&#7885; v&#7851;n c&oacute; BTC v&agrave; token v&#7851;n c&oacute; gi&aacute; 90,000-92,000 USD, ho&#7863;c gi&aacute; n&agrave;o &#273;&oacute; tr&ecirc;n th&#7883; tr&#432;&#7901;ng hi&#7879;n t&#7841;i. V&igrave; v&#7853;y, h&#7885; kh&ocirc;ng nh&#7853;n ra r&#7857;ng h&#7885; &#273;&atilde; m&#7845;t ti&#7873;n. Nh&#432;ng n&#7871;u h&#7885; c&#7889; g&#7855;ng tho&aacute;t ra, &#273;&oacute; l&agrave; khi h&#7885; s&#7869; nh&#7853;n ra l&agrave; &#273;&atilde; m&#7845;t.&rdquo;
</blockquote>

<h2 class="bic-gutenberg-heading wp-heading wp-block-heading" id="h-bitcoin-enables-transfer-of-wealth-from-buyers-to-sellers">&ldquo;Bitcoin t&#7841;o &#273;i&#7873;u ki&#7879;n chuy&#7875;n giao t&agrave;i s&#7843;n t&#7915; ng&#432;&#7901;i mua sang ng&#432;&#7901;i b&aacute;n&rdquo;</h2>

&#272;i&#7873;u n&agrave;y &#273;&uacute;ng &#273;&#7871;n m&#7913;c b&#7845;t k&#7923; t&agrave;i s&#7843;n n&agrave;o giao d&#7883;ch t&#7921; do, nh&#432; c&#7893; phi&#7871;u, v&agrave;ng, &#273;&#7845;t &#273;ai, ngh&#7879; thu&#7853;t cao c&#7845;p, c&#361;ng chuy&#7875;n giao t&agrave;i s&#7843;n gi&#7919;a c&aacute;c b&ecirc;n tham gia d&#7921;a tr&ecirc;n gi&aacute; &#273;&#7847;u v&agrave;o, gi&aacute; &#273;&#7847;u ra, v&agrave; t&igrave;nh h&igrave;nh th&#7883; tr&#432;&#7901;ng.
Nh&#432;ng <a href="https://vn.beincrypto.com/peter-schiff-to-cz-bitcoin-gold/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">Schiff cho r&#7857;ng s&#7921; chuy&#7875;n giao n&agrave;y l&agrave; t&#7893;ng b&#7857;ng kh&ocirc;ng</a>. &#272;i&#7873;u &#273;&oacute; kh&ocirc;ng ch&iacute;nh x&aacute;c. M&#7841;ng l&#432;&#7899;i c&#7911;a Bitcoin t&#7921; n&oacute; t&#7841;o ra ti&#7879;n &iacute;ch, &#273;i&#7873;u n&agrave;y kh&aacute;c bi&#7879;t so v&#7899;i gi&aacute; c&#7843;.
Bitcoin ng&agrave;y nay mang l&#7841;i kh&#7843; n&#259;ng thanh to&aacute;n xuy&ecirc;n bi&ecirc;n gi&#7899;i, ho&#7841;t &#273;&#7897;ng nh&#432; m&#7897;t n&#417;i l&#432;u tr&#7919; gi&aacute; tr&#7883; kh&ocirc;ng b&#7883; ki&#7875;m duy&#7879;t v&agrave; l&agrave;m t&agrave;i s&#7843;n th&#7871; ch&#7845;p tr&ecirc;n c&aacute;c n&#7873;n t&#7843;ng t&agrave;i ch&iacute;nh.
Gi&aacute; tr&#7883; &#273;&#432;&#7907;c t&#7841;o ra qua kh&#7843; n&#259;ng ch&#7913; kh&ocirc;ng ch&#7881; l&agrave; h&igrave;nh th&#7913;c v&#7853;t ch&#7845;t. M&#7897;t m&#7841;ng l&#432;&#7899;i to&agrave;n c&#7847;u di chuy&#7875;n v&#7889;n ngay l&#7853;p t&#7913;c m&agrave; kh&ocirc;ng c&#7847;n ng&acirc;n h&agrave;ng hay trung gian l&agrave; m&#7897;t ch&#7913;c n&#259;ng kinh t&#7871; m&#7899;i. &#272;&oacute; l&agrave; t&#7841;o ra t&agrave;i s&#7843;n theo &#273;&#7883;nh ngh&#297;a.
N&#7871;u Bitcoin ch&#7881; &#273;&#417;n thu&#7847;n ph&acirc;n ph&#7889;i l&#7841;i gi&aacute; tr&#7883;, th&igrave; n&oacute; s&#7869; kh&ocirc;ng l&agrave;m n&#7873;n t&#7843;ng cho c&aacute;c k&ecirc;nh thanh to&aacute;n, n&#7873;n t&#7843;ng l&#432;u k&yacute;, hay c&aacute;c <a href="https://vn.beincrypto.com/western-union-stablecoin-pilot/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">&#273;&#432;&#7901;ng giao d&#7883;ch h&agrave;ng t&#7927; USD</a>.
M&#7897;t t&agrave;i s&#7843;n t&#7893;ng b&#7857;ng kh&ocirc;ng kh&ocirc;ng thu h&uacute;t kho b&#7841;c doanh nghi&#7879;p, qu&#7929; ETF c&#7911;a t&#7893; ch&#7913;c, hay s&#7921; ch&#7845;p nh&#7853;n c&#7911;a c&aacute;c qu&#7889;c gia.
<h2 class="bic-gutenberg-heading wp-heading wp-block-heading" id="h-no-real-wealth-was-created-by-the-addition-of-20-million-bitcoin">&ldquo;Kh&ocirc;ng c&oacute; t&agrave;i s&#7843;n th&#7853;t n&agrave;o &#273;&#432;&#7907;c t&#7841;o ra b&#7903;i vi&#7879;c th&ecirc;m 20 tri&#7879;u Bitcoin&rdquo;</h2>

T&agrave;i s&#7843;n kh&ocirc;ng ph&#7909; thu&#7897;c v&agrave;o ch&#7845;t li&#7879;u v&#7853;t l&yacute;. N&oacute; ph&#7909; thu&#7897;c v&agrave;o nhu c&#7847;u, ti&#7879;n &iacute;ch, s&#7921; &#273;&#7891;ng thu&#7853;n, v&agrave; kh&#7843; n&#259;ng b&#7843;o to&agrave;n ho&#7863;c chuy&#7875;n giao gi&aacute; tr&#7883;.
L&#7853;p lu&#7853;n c&#7911;a Schiff c&oacute; th&#7875; &aacute;p d&#7909;ng l&#7883;ch s&#7917; cho:
<ul class="bic-gutenberg-list wp-list list-disc ">
<li>Ti&#7873;n gi&#7845;y do ch&iacute;nh ph&#7911; ph&aacute;t h&agrave;nh (t&#7841;o ra b&#7857;ng tuy&ecirc;n b&#7889;, nh&#432;ng &#273;&#432;&#7907;c ch&#7845;p nh&#7853;n to&agrave;n c&#7847;u).</li>

<li>T&ecirc;n mi&#7873;n Internet (kh&ocirc;ng v&#7853;t l&yacute;, nh&#432;ng l&agrave; t&agrave;i s&#7843;n &#273;&aacute;ng gi&aacute; h&agrave;ng tri&#7879;u USD).</li>

<li>Ph&#7847;n m&#7873;m v&agrave; h&#7841; t&#7847;ng &#273;&aacute;m m&acirc;y (v&ocirc; h&igrave;nh, nh&#432;ng quan tr&#7885;ng v&#7899;i GDP to&agrave;n c&#7847;u).</li>
</ul>

Theo ti&ecirc;u chu&#7849;n &#273;&oacute;, ph&#7847;n m&#7873;m, kh&ocirc;ng gian DNS Internet, <a href="https://vn.beincrypto.com/bitcoin-underperforms-stocks-gold-analysis/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">m&ocirc; h&igrave;nh AI</a>, v&agrave; th&#7853;m ch&iacute; ti&#7873;n ph&aacute;p &#273;&#7883;nh c&#361;ng kh&ocirc;ng &#273;&#432;&#7907;c coi l&agrave; t&agrave;i s&#7843;n. Tuy nhi&ecirc;n, nh&#7919;ng h&#7879; th&#7889;ng v&ocirc; h&igrave;nh n&agrave;y l&agrave; &#273;&#7897;ng l&#7921;c kinh t&#7871; hi&#7879;n nay.Bitcoin &#273;&atilde; t&#7841;o ra m&#7897;t th&#7913; ch&#432;a t&#7915;ng c&oacute; trong l&#7883;ch s&#7917; ti&#7873;n t&#7879;: m&#7897;t t&agrave;i s&#7843;n v&ocirc; danh di chuy&#7875;n nh&#432; d&#7919; li&#7879;u, thanh to&aacute;n m&agrave; kh&ocirc;ng c&#7847;n trung gian, v&agrave; c&oacute; th&#7875; ki&#7875;m ch&#7913;ng b&#7857;ng to&aacute;n h&#7885;c.
&#272;&#7863;c &#273;i&#7875;m &#273;&oacute; t&#432;&#417;ng &#273;&#432;&#417;ng v&#7899;i <a href="https://vn.beincrypto.com/why-tokenized-gold-is-growing/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">s&#7889; h&oacute;a v&agrave;ng</a> nh&#432;ng kh&ocirc;ng c&oacute; r&agrave;o c&#7843;n v&#7873; l&#432;u tr&#7919;, v&#7853;n chuy&#7875;n, hay ki&#7875;m &#273;&#7883;nh.
T&agrave;i s&#7843;n &#273;&atilde; &#273;&#432;&#7907;c t&#7841;o ra v&igrave; c&aacute;c kh&#7843; n&#259;ng m&#7899;i &#273;&atilde; xu&#7845;t hi&#7879;n.
<h2 class="bic-gutenberg-heading wp-heading wp-block-heading" id="h-moi-nguoi-chi-khong-biet-ho-da-mat-tien-vi-gia-van-cao">&ldquo;M&#7885;i ng&#432;&#7901;i ch&#7881; kh&ocirc;ng bi&#7871;t h&#7885; &#273;&atilde; m&#7845;t ti&#7873;n v&igrave; gi&aacute; v&#7851;n cao&rdquo;</h2>

&#272;i&#7873;u n&agrave;y d&#7921;a tr&ecirc;n gi&#7843; &#273;&#7883;nh r&#7857;ng Bitcoin s&#7869; s&#7909;p &#273;&#7893;. &#272;i&#7873;u &#273;&oacute; c&oacute; th&#7875; x&#7843;y ra &mdash; nh&#432;ng kh&ocirc;ng ph&#7843;i l&agrave; th&#7921;c t&#7871;, n&oacute; l&agrave; m&#7897;t d&#7921; b&aacute;o.
N&#7871;u <a href="https://vn.beincrypto.com/vanguard-crypto-ban-ends-bitcoin-solana-xrp-trading-opens/" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">Bitcoin ti&#7871;p t&#7909;c &#273;&#432;&#7907;c y&ecirc;u c&#7847;u to&agrave;n c&#7847;u</a>, s&#7921; khan hi&#7871;m v&agrave; ph&aacute;t tri&#7875;n m&#7841;ng l&#432;&#7899;i gi&#7919; v&#7919;ng gi&aacute; tr&#7883;.
N&#7871;u s&#7921; ch&#7845;p nh&#7853;n t&#259;ng tr&#432;&#7903;ng th&ecirc;m &mdash; nh&#432; &#273;&atilde; x&#7843;y ra v&#7899;i ETF, kho b&#7841;c doanh nghi&#7879;p, v&agrave; l&#432;u k&yacute; qu&#7889;c gia &mdash; th&igrave; d&#7921; &#273;o&aacute;n c&#7911;a Schiff s&#7869; y&#7871;u &#273;i.
Quan &#273;i&#7875;m c&#7911;a &ocirc;ng &#7845;y xem l&#7907;i nhu&#7853;n ch&#432;a th&#7921;c hi&#7879;n l&agrave; &#7843;o t&#432;&#7903;ng. Nh&#432;ng:
<ul class="bic-gutenberg-list wp-list list-disc ">
<li>N&#7871;u ai &#273;&oacute; gi&#7919; Bitcoin trong 10 n&#259;m v&agrave; sau &#273;&oacute; b&aacute;n &#7903; gi&aacute; cao h&#417;n, t&agrave;i s&#7843;n &#273;&#432;&#7907;c hi&#7879;n th&#7921;c h&oacute;a.</li>

<li>N&#7871;u Bitcoin &#273;&#432;&#7907;c giao d&#7883;ch r&#7897;ng r&atilde;i v&agrave; t&iacute;ch h&#7907;p v&agrave;o h&#7841; t&#7847;ng ti&#7873;n t&#7879;, t&agrave;i s&#7843;n ho&#7841;t &#273;&#7897;ng v&#432;&#7907;t qua s&#7921; &#273;&#7847;u c&#417;.</li>
</ul>

Lu&#7853;n thuy&#7871;t c&#7911;a &ocirc;ng ch&#7881; &#273;&uacute;ng n&#7871;u Bitcoin th&#7845;t b&#7841;i nh&#432; m&#7897;t m&#7841;ng l&#432;&#7899;i ti&#7873;n t&#7879;. V&agrave; h&#417;n m&#7897;t th&#7853;p k&#7927; ph&aacute;t tri&#7875;n cho th&#7845;y h&#432;&#7899;ng &#273;i ng&#432;&#7907;c l&#7841;i.
<h2 class="bic-gutenberg-heading wp-heading wp-block-heading" id="h-conclusion">K&#7871;t lu&#7853;n</h2>

Nh&#7919;ng b&igrave;nh lu&#7853;n c&#7911;a Peter Schiff &#273;&atilde; thu h&uacute;t s&#7921; ch&uacute; &yacute; v&agrave; g&acirc;y ra nh&#7919;ng cu&#7897;c th&#7843;o lu&#7853;n, nh&#432;ng l&#7853;p lu&#7853;n c&#7911;a &ocirc;ng b&#7887; qua c&aacute;c th&#7921;c t&#7871; kinh t&#7871; quan tr&#7885;ng.
Bitcoin kh&ocirc;ng ch&#7881; &#273;&#417;n thu&#7847;n l&agrave; m&#7897;t chuy&#7875;n giao t&agrave;i s&#7843;n. N&oacute; l&agrave; m&#7897;t m&#7841;ng l&#432;&#7899;i ti&#7873;n t&#7879; to&agrave;n c&#7847;u ho&#7841;t &#273;&#7897;ng v&#7899;i nh&#7919;ng &#273;&#7863;c &#273;i&#7875;m m&agrave; kh&ocirc;ng lo&#7841;i n&agrave;o t&agrave;i s&#7843;n truy&#7873;n th&#7889;ng n&agrave;o c&oacute; th&#7875; so s&aacute;nh.
Lu&#7853;n &#273;i&#7875;m r&#7857;ng n&oacute; &ldquo;kh&ocirc;ng t&#7841;o ra t&agrave;i s&#7843;n&rdquo; d&#7921;a tr&ecirc;n nh&#7919;ng gi&#7843; &#273;&#7883;nh l&#7895;i th&#7901;i v&#7873; ngu&#7891;n g&#7889;c gi&aacute; tr&#7883;.

Bình luận về Bitcoin của Peter Schiff tại buổi tranh luận với CZ có có lỗi logic